A Commonwealth entity identified potential non-compliance associated with the administration of payments. The matter was disclosed through the entity’s established reporting arrangements, and corrective action was taken to address the immediate issues.
To obtain further assurance, the accountable authority commissioned a management-initiated review led by the entity’s internal audit function. The review examined whether the corrective actions were appropriate and effective, and whether further improvements were needed.
The review identified opportunities to strengthen controls across the payment lifecycle. In particular, some controls continued to rely on:
- manual processes
- individual judgement
- informal coordination between relevant areas.
These limitations reduced the entity’s ability to obtain end-to-end assurance that payments were consistently processed in accordance with relevant requirements.
Entity response
The entity agreed to pursue further improvements to strengthen the design, consistency and enforceability of its payment controls. It also continued reviewing relevant risks and authorisations and retained established arrangements for reporting any further potential non-compliance.
Lessons
This example demonstrates that a control incident does not necessarily mean an entity’s overall system of internal control is ineffective. However, it may identify weaknesses in how individual controls operate together.
A targeted internal audit or independent review can help an accountable authority:
- assess whether corrective actions have addressed the immediate issue
- understand the underlying causes of control failure
- identify residual risks and opportunities for improvement
- obtain assurance that controls are appropriately designed and operating as intended
- support continuous improvement without introducing unnecessary controls.