Role of audit committees for non-corporate Commonwealth entities
On this page
Introduction
Link copiedAudit committees play an important role in supporting the governance of non-corporate Commonwealth entities (NCEs), providing independent advice to accountable authorities, assisting them to meet their duties and obligations and supporting the development of key practice and capacity within NCEs.
Under the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (PGPA Act), accountable authorities have both financial and non-financial reporting obligations which require them to produce financial statements and non-financial performance statements in their annual reports. In addition to their more traditional roles, the functions of an audit committee under the PGPA Act include reviewing the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s performance reporting for the entity, with a focus on non-financial performance reporting (section 17 of the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Rule 2014 (PGPA Rule)).
To assist accountable authorities to meet their performance reporting obligations, audit committees need appropriate qualifications, knowledge, skills and experience. This includes maintaining a good understanding of the entity’s unique operating environment and the risks faced by the entity to provide useful and relevant advice on non-financial performance reporting.
An audit committee has no managerial responsibilities. It does not make decisions in relation to the entity’s processes and functions. It is intended to provide independent advice to the accountable authority. This advice may be used by an accountable authority in discharging their duties and obligations. Importantly, this advice is one of the key sources of information available to an accountable authority to consider when preparing formal statements to their responsible Minister and the Parliament about the information contained in annual financial statements (with reference to sections 41 and 42 of the PGPA Act) and annual performance statements (with reference to section 39 of the PGPA Act).
Since the introduction of the PGPA Act, improving the non-financial performance reporting of Commonwealth entities remains a key area of focus for Parliament. The Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit (JCPAA) has made a number of recommendations to raise the profile and quality of performance reporting within entities including mandatory annual audits of performance statements by the Auditor-General.
This guide, together with other Department of Finance guidance such as the Commonwealth Performance Framework, helps frame the work of an audit committee. It covers the required elements of an audit committee’s written charter and matters the accountable authority may consider when determining the committee’s functions, structure and conduct. It can be used with the Model Audit Committee Charter when developing an entity’s charter.
Elements of the audit committee charter
Link copiedUnder the PGPA Rule, the accountable authority of a Commonwealth entity must determine the functions of the entity’s audit committee by written charter (the charter) (subsection 17(1)). The charter is the accountable authority’s blueprint for the audit committee’s operations.
Each non-corporate Commonwealth entity’s audit committee charter must be publicly available through its annual report via a direct electronic address included in their annual report (PGPA Rule s.17AG(2A)).
The PGPA Rule states the functions must include reviewing the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s: financial reporting, performance reporting, system of risk oversight and management, and the system of internal control for the entity (subsection 17(2)). Once these mandatory requirements are met, the accountable authority may specify other functions or matters relevant to the operation of the audit committee. The charter should be developed to meet the needs of the accountable authority, allowing for its entity’s objectives and culture, and the context in which it operates.
When developing their written charter, the accountable authority may consider:
-
audit committee’s functions and responsibilities, including any functions the accountable authority may want to add in addition to the legislative functions under the PGPA Rule
-
audit committee’s anticipated deliverables, with the content and level of detail expected in the advice the committee provides
-
the membership of the audit committee—including relevant skills and qualifications
-
the conduct of the audit committee—including communications with officials of the entity and the Australian National Audit Office (ANAO), administrative arrangements relating to meetings, and processes for managing potential conflicts of interest
-
the period for which audit committee members will be appointed, allowing for short-term membership
-
a requirement for access to all information necessary to enable the audit committee to effectively advise the accountable authority on the committee’s functions
-
the entity’s specific operating context, which the audit committee must consider when performing its functions
-
how the performance of the audit committee will be assessed.
The charter should be updated at least annually to reflect changes to the entity’s operating context, new circumstances, the accountable authority’s changing needs and to ensure it aligns with the current risks, challenges and opportunities the entity faces.
Functions of the audit committee
Link copiedThe Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Rule 2014 (PGPA Rule) requires that an accountable authority of a Commonwealth entity determine by written charter, the functions of the audit committee established for the entity (subsection 17(1)). Those functions must include reviewing the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s financial and performance reporting, risk oversight and management systems, and internal control, for the entity. Advice from the audit committee assists the accountable authority to meet its broader duties and responsibilities under the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (PGPA Act).
The charter should ensure that the committee and other stakeholders are clear about the required functions and responsibilities. The accountable authority may also describe how the committee will conduct its reviews. This can include expectations for formal and informal communication, and how to record and retain the committee’s advice.
In its independent capacity and using collective skills and experience, the audit committee reviews the information provided to it by internal audit and the entity’s management. The committee also actively pursues information from relevant areas of the entity to understand and review the entity’s processes.
Financial reporting review
The PGPA Rule requires that the audit committee review the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s financial reporting for the entity (subsection 17(2)(a)). This includes reviewing whether the entity’s financial reporting and financial information systems meet the requirements of the PGPA Act, Rule, and the Accounting Standards.
By conducting this review, the audit committee supports the accountable authority to meet their obligations under the PGPA Act for the entity’s accounts, records and financial reporting.
Financial record-keeping and reporting duties of accountable authorities
The PGPA Act requires an accountable authority of a Commonwealth entity to do the following:
- govern the entity in a way that promotes the proper use and management of public resources (subsection 15(a)) and promotes the financial sustainability of the entity (subsection 15(c))
- cause accounts and records to be kept that properly detail and explain the entity’s transactions and financial position (subsection 41(1))
- ensure the accounts and records are kept in a way that complies with any requirements prescribed by the rules, enables the preparation of the annual financial statements required by sections 42 (Commonwealth entities) and 48 (Australian Government), and allows those financial statements to be conveniently and properly audited
- prepare, as soon as practicable after the end of the reporting period, annual financial statements for the entity that comply with the accounting standards and any other requirements prescribed by the rules (subsection 42(1)) and present fairly the entity’s financial position, financial performance and cash flows (subsection 42(2)).
It is a requirement of the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability (Financial Reporting) Rule 2015 (the FRR) that the accountable authority of a Commonwealth entity provide signed certification stating the following:
- whether the annual financial statements, in its view, comply with subsection 42(2) of the PGPA Act (subsection 10(a))
- whether the annual financial statements, in its view, have been prepared on the basis of properly maintained financial records as per subsection 41(2) of the PGPA Act and other requirements (subsections10(b) to 10(g)).
The FRR requires that information not reported in the Commonwealth entity’s annual financial statements but required as part of the Australian Government consolidated financial statements, be made available to the Department of Finance at the time and in the format required (subsection 18(4)).
Further information about an accountable authority’s financial reporting requirements is available on Financial reporting and accounting policy.
Role and functions of the audit committee
Audit committees could fulfil the financial reporting review function under subsection 17(2)(a) of the PGPA Rule by:
- reviewing the entity’s processes and systems for preparing financial reporting information
- reviewing the processes in place to allow the entity to stay informed throughout the year of any changes or additional requirements in relation to financial reporting
- reviewing the annual financial statements.
Audit committee deliverables – Financial reporting
An audit committee’s charter should specify the content and level of detail expected in a written advice by the audit committee to the accountable authority about the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s financial reporting.
Consistent with the requirements of accountable authorities under the PGPA Act regarding accounts, records and the preparation of annual financial statements, the advice to the accountable authority from its audit committee should be documented in the form of a written statement of its view of the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s financial reporting.
The audit committee should communicate their view to the accountable authority and not merely state that it does not know of anything that would indicate the accountable authority’s financial reporting for the entity is not appropriate. The statement adds value by providing comfort to the accountable authority that their financial reporting is appropriate, and by providing references and suggestions for systems and process improvement.
Through the audit committee charter, for example, an accountable authority could require the committee to produce a statement:
- as to whether the annual financial statements, in the committee’s view, comply with the PGPA Act, the PGPA Rules, the Accounting Standards and supporting guidance
- as to whether additional entity information (other than financial statements) required by Finance for the purpose of preparing the Australian Government consolidated financial statements (including the supplementary reporting package) comply with the PGPA Act, the PGPA Rules, the Accounting Standards and supporting guidance
- to the accountable authority in respect of the appropriateness of the entity’s financial reporting as a whole, with reference to any specific areas of concern or suggestions for improvement.
Performance reporting review
Under the PGPA Act and Rule accountable authorities have a number of duties, and obligations, relating to the performance of Commonwealth entities; this includes the preparation of annual performance statements. Audit committees can support accountable authorities by providing independent advice to the accountable authority through reviewing the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s performance reporting. An understanding of the accountable authority’s performance reporting duties and obligations is essential if an audit committee is to perform this function effectively.
By conducting this review, the audit committee supports the accountable authority meet obligations under the PGPA Act for the entity’s performance reporting.
Performance reporting duties of the accountable authority
The PGPA Act requires that the accountable authority of a Commonwealth entity:
- govern the entity in a way that promotes the achievement of the purposes of the entity (subsection 15(1)(b))
- prepare a corporate plan for the entity at least once each reporting period (subsection 35(1))
- cause records to be kept that properly detail and explain the entity’s performance in achieving its purposes (subsection 37(1)) and enable the preparation of annual performance statements (subsection 37(2))
- measure and assess the performance of the entity in achieving its purposes in compliance with the PGPA Rule (subsections 38(1) and 38(2))
- prepare annual performance statements that provide information about the entity’s performance in achieving its purposes (subsection 39(2) (a)).
The PGPA Rule contains further details, providing that the accountable authority of a Commonwealth entity must do the following:
- produce a corporate plan for the entity that includes the purposes of the entity, its key activities, the operating context and details of how the performance of the entity in achieving its purposes will be measured and assessed (section 16E)
- produce annual performance statements that sets out the result of the measurement and assessment outlined in the corporate plan and any related budget statements (section 16F).
The Finance Secretary’s Direction – Requirements for Performance Information included in Portfolio Budget Statements (PBS) sets out what n entity must do in respect to the provision of performance information in the PBS. For further information on the PBS performance reporting requirements, refer to RMG-129 Reporting performance information in Portfolio Budget Statements.
Role and functions of the audit committee - Performance reporting
Under the PGPA Rule, audit committees are required to review the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s performance reporting for the entity (subsection 17(2)(b)).
To fulfill this function, an audit committee must review the entity’s performance information, systems and framework and the completeness and appropriateness of performance reporting. The review would include information provided in the corporate plan, the PBS and the annual performance statements.
The establishment of a performance framework across Commonwealth entities is a key element of the PGPA Act. The Commonwealth performance framework diagram outlines the key components of the framework.
The Commonwealth performance framework is supported by the corporate plan, Portfolio Budget Statements and annual performance statements. These publications work together to describe an entity’s purposes, planned activities, resourcing and performance results.
The corporate plan is the primary planning document for a Commonwealth entity. It sets out the entity’s purposes, the key activities it will undertake to achieve those purposes, and how the entity’s performance will be measured and assessed over a minimum 4-year period. The corporate plan also describes the environment in which the entity operates, the capability it requires, its approach to risk oversight and management, and how it will cooperate with others, including subsidiaries, to achieve its purposes.
Portfolio Budget Statements are prepared on a portfolio basis and support annual appropriations. They inform Senators and Members of Parliament about the proposed allocation of resources to government outcomes and programs. They include performance information for current and ongoing programs, and more detailed performance information for proposed new budget measures that require a new program or materially change an existing program. Portfolio Budget Statements also provide links to relevant programs undertaken by other Commonwealth entities and connect to the corporate plan by reporting key activities expressed in the current corporate plan.
Annual performance statements are included in the Commonwealth entity’s annual report. They report on the entity’s actual performance results for the reporting year, as set out in the corporate plan and Portfolio Budget Statements. They also provide analysis of factors that may have contributed to the entity’s performance results.
Audit committees can have a significant role in assisting entities in undertaking a review of their approach to performance reporting.
Performance measures must meet the requirements under sections 16E(2) item 5 and 16EA of the PGPA Rule. For further guidance on each requirement, refer to RMG-131 Developing performance measures. RMG 131, along with ANAO reports on the implementation of annual performance statements audits should assist audit committees in assessing the appropriateness of an entity’s performance reporting.
Activities the audit committee could undertake to fulfil its review function:
- review the entity’s systems and procedures for assessing, monitoring and reporting on the entity’s performance. In particular, the committee could satisfy itself that:
- the entity’s PBS and corporate plan contain appropriate details of how the entity’s performance will be measured and assessed
- the entity’s approach to measuring its performance against the performance measures included in its PBS and corporate plan is appropriate and in accordance with the Commonwealth performance framework. This may include periodically reviewing particular elements of the performance measures
- the entity has appropriate systems and processes for preparation of its annual performance statements and inclusion of the statements in its annual report
- review the annual performance statements and provide advice to the accountable authority on their appropriateness to the entity.
Audit committee deliverables – Performance reporting
Consistent with the requirements on accountable authorities under the PGPA Act regarding records about performance (section 37), advice to the accountable authority from the audit committee should be documented in the form of a written statement of its view on the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s performance reporting. An audit committee’s charter should specify the content and level of detail expected in a written advice.
The audit committee should communicate their view to the accountable authority and not merely state that it does not know of anything that would indicate the accountable authority’s performance reporting for the entity is not appropriate. The statement adds value by providing comfort to the accountable authority that their performance reporting is appropriate, and by providing references and suggestions for systems and process improvement.
For example, through the audit committee charter, an accountable authority could require the following:
- a statement of the audit committee’s view in relation to the appropriateness of the entity’s annual performance statements, and the performance reporting as a whole, compliance with the PGPA Act and Rule, with reference to any specific suggestions for improvement or areas of concern.
System of risk oversight and management review
Link copiedThe PGPA Act places a duty on the accountable authority to establish and maintain an appropriate system of risk oversight and management for the entity. To promote a coherent approach to discharging this duty and to help entities understand the requirements for managing risk, in 2014 the Australian Government released the Commonwealth Risk Management Policy (CRMP).
By conducting this review, the audit committee supports the accountable authority to meet obligations under the PGPA Act for the entity’s system of risk oversight and management.
Risk management duties of the accountable authority
Commonwealth entity accountable authorities are required to establish and maintain an appropriate risk oversight and management system for the entity (subsection 16(a)). Accountable authorities of non-corporate Commonwealth entities (NCEs) must comply with the CRMP.
The goal of the CRMP is to embed risk management as part of the culture of Commonwealth entities such that a shared understanding of risk leads to well-informed decision-making.
The policy’s requirements are organised into nine policy elements (see Figure 3). Further guidance on the policy is available in RMG-211 Implementing the Commonwealth Risk Management Policy. For further information on an accountable authority’s system of risk oversight and management see the Risk Management Services.
Role and functions of the audit committee - Risk management
The audit committee supports the accountable authority in relation to risk management by reviewing the appropriateness of its system of risk oversight and management, informed by the entity’s purposes and specific operating context. For example, the audit committee of an entity managing large grants programs may focus on risks associated with the implementation and delivery of grants whereas the audit committee of an entity managing large procurements may focus on risks associated with significant or complex procurement activity.
This aspect of the audit committee’s role includes reviewing whether identified risks and their treatments are consistent with the entity’s operating context and experience in risk management.
The following are examples of the activities the audit committee could undertake to fulfil its review function:
- review whether there is a current and appropriate enterprise risk management policy framework, and the necessary internal controls for the effective identification and management of the entity’s risks, consistent with the CRMP.
- satisfy itself that an appropriate approach has been followed in managing the entity’s key risks—including those associated with individual projects, procurements and program implementation and activities
- review the process of developing and implementing the entity’s fraud control arrangements consistent with the fraud control framework, and satisfy itself that the entity has adequate processes for detecting, capturing and effectively responding to fraud risks
- review whether management has adequately developed risk management capability in the entity and whether key risk management roles, responsibilities and authorities are clearly articulated and adhered to in the entity.
Audit committee deliverables - Risk management
Audit committee deliverables - Risk management An audit committee should document their advice to the accountable authority in the form of a statement of its view in relation to the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s risk oversight and management systems. This advice should confirm whether the entity’s risk framework is suitable and highlights any areas of concern, rather than make a simple assertion that it does not know of anything that would indicate the accountable authority’s system of risk oversight management is not appropriate for the entity. This statement adds value by providing comfort to the accountable authority that their risk system is appropriate, and by providing references and suggestions for systems and process improvement.
For example, through the audit committee charter an accountable authority could require:
- a statement to the accountable authority in relation to the overall appropriateness of the entity’s systems for of risk oversight and management arrangements.
System of internal control review
Link copiedAudit committees assist accountable authorities by reviewing the appropriateness of the internal control system in place and providing independent advice. To perform this effectively, audit committees are required to have an understanding of the entity’s internal control framework, operating context and accountable authority’s risk appetite.
By conducting this review the committee supports the accountable authority to meet obligations under the PGPA Act for the entity’s system of internal control.
Internal control duties of the accountable authority
Accountable authorities are responsible for leading, governing and setting the strategic direction for their entities. As part of this, they must ensure their own (and their entity’s) compliance with various Commonwealth legislative and policy requirements, including the following:
-
any enabling legislation
-
employment legislation—including the Public Service Act 1999and the Work Health and Safety Act 2011
-
information management legislation—including freedom of information requirements and the Privacy Act 1988.
Accountable authorities are expected to establish and maintain other systems and processes that facilitate good governance—for example, internal audit processes, business continuity management, and promotion of a positive entity culture.
Further information about an accountable authority’s system of internal control obligation can be found in RMG-205 Strengthening Internal Controls
The PGPA Act requires that the accountable authority of a Commonwealth entity:
-
govern the entity in a way that promotes the proper use and management of public resources (subsection 15(a))
-
establish and maintain an appropriate system of internal control for the entity (subsection 16(b))
-
implement measures directed at ensuring that officials of the entity comply with the finance law (section 16).
To assist in meeting these obligations, the accountable authority of a Commonwealth entity may, by written instrument, give instructions to an official of the entity in respect of any matter relating to the finance law (subsection 20A(1)).
The accountable authority of a non-corporate Commonwealth entity can delegate to officials certain powers and functions described in the PGPA Act or Rule. For example, it can delegate the power to commit relevant money (section 110 of the PGPA Act). If a non-corporate Commonwealth entity is subject to enabling legislation, the accountable authority might also be able to delegate or authorise officials to exercise functions and powers under that legislation.
Role and functions of the audit committee - Internal controls
Audit committees are required to review the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s system of internal control for the entity (subsection 17(2)(d)).
The accountable authority can expect that the committee take a risk-based approach to reviewing the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s system of internal control. This includes whether the key elements of internal control are present. The frequency of review, and areas of the system of internal control to be reviewed, will be guided by the accountable authority’s requirements, appetite for risk and the entity’s operating context.
Although a detailed assessment of the internal control system is beyond the ordinary scope of the audit committee role, its review of the adequacy and relevance of the entity’s financial and non-financial internal control could be informed by the entity’s purposes and specific operating context. For example, the audit committee of an entity that processes payments may focus on the integrity of the processes for managing those transactions, while the audit committee of an entity that maintains personal information may focus on internal control around protection of that information.
Internal audit can support audit committees by suggesting, and delivering reports on the entity’s current risks affecting internal control.
The committee may undertake the following activities:
-
internal control framework
-
reviewing management’s approach to maintaining an effective internal control framework and whether appropriate processes exist to ensure compliance with key policies and procedures
-
reviewing whether relevant policies and procedures are in place (for example, accountable authority instructions, delegations, a business continuity management plan, or bullying and harassment policies
-
legislative and policy compliance
-
reviewing the effectiveness of systems for monitoring the entity’s compliance with laws, regulations and associated government policies
-
determining whether management has adequately considered legal and compliance risks in their risk management framework and fraud control framework and planning
-
procurement
-
reviewing the effectiveness of internal controls and processes in place to manage significant and/or complex procurement activity and ensure they are current and fit for purpose.
-
security compliance
-
reviewing management’s approach to maintaining an effective internal security system including complying with the Protective Security Policy Framework.
-
internal audit coverage
-
reviewing the proposed internal audit coverage to ensure it addresses primary risks, particularly where the entity engages in significant or complex procurement activity, and recommending approval of the internal audit work plan by the accountable authority or the nominated delegate
-
reviewing all internal audit reports, advising the accountable authority on major concerns, and recommending action on significant matters, including sharing good practice examples.
-
external audit and reviews
-
reviewing external reports (Auditor-General, Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audi (JCPAA) and other parliamentary committees, Royal Commissions etc.), and the entity-relevant recommendations, and
-
reviewing the implementation of agreed recommendations from ANAO audits or JCPAA and other parliamentary committee reports directed to the entity.
Audit committee deliverables – Internal controls
The audit committee is expected to document advice to the accountable authority in the form of a statement of its view on the appropriateness of the accountable authority’s system of internal control. The frequency and nature of this advice should align with the accountable authority’s requirements, risk appetite and the entity’s operating context. This advice should confirm whether the entity’s system of internal control is appropriate and highlight any areas of concern, rather than make a simple assertion that it does not know of anything that would indicate the accountable authority’s system of internal control is not appropriate for the entity.
For example, through the audit committee charter an accountable authority could require:
-
a statement to the accountable authority in relation to the appropriateness of the entity’s systems for internal control, with reference to specific areas of concern or suggestions for improvement.
Policies, legislation and guidelines
Link copiedResource management guides
Link copiedGlossary
Link copied- Accountable authority
- Appropriateness
- Audit committee
- Commonwealth entity