The objective of Stage 4 is to monitor and evaluate the activity, while ensuring appropriate transparency, accountability and performance.

Review of the charging model

As a default, regulatory cost elements are to be reviewed on an annual basis. Costs must be set to confirm the current minimum efficient costs as evidenced by a process assessment and actual costs from the previous year before charges are indexed. This process ensures charges reflect the ongoing efficient costs of delivering the activity.

The indexation process should consider review of individual cost elements to ensure correct cost elements are being indexed instead of applying indexation to the entire charge. Activities are only exempted from indexation if policy outcomes are significantly adversely impacted and this determination may require the Government decision.

The treatment of changes to regulatory charges also depends on the risk assessment (complexity, materiality and sensitivity of the charge to the user or Government) and the total costs and revenues to the Government.

When reviewing a charging model, entities should ensure that appropriate mechanisms are in place that allow the entity to:

  • review and validate business processes, outputs and activities
  • review and validate direct and indirect costs elements, including proxies and applying appropriate annual indexation
  • review and validate cost attribution to business processes, outputs and activities
  • respond to variation in demand
  • benchmark the business processes, outputs or activities.

Entities should consider risk mitigation strategies when designing performance and monitoring for charges, which if triggered, result in a review of the charging model, demand assumptions and/or the level of the price.

Changes to existing charges and the charging model (costs/prices) 

When reviewing existing charging, entities should consider whether the policy intent of the activity is being met, and how the charging (price level) effect the policy objectives.

Over time, a charge may no longer be consistent with government policy priorities or may become inefficient. In such circumstances, entities should consider whether the activity of charging or the charge should be reviewed to determine how efficiencies will improve costs and charges to benefit individuals or organisations. Entities could align yearly reviews with preparation of the Financial Statements for Annual Reports and Corporate Plans

Entities may need to make changes to their charging as a result of changes in cost inputs, stakeholder feedback, policy changes or internal monitoring and evaluation. The nature of the changes will determine how they should be approved and implemented. Entities may need to seek advice on the potential policy or legal implications of expected or potential changes to the charging activity.

There are two broad types of changes to charging activities:

  • operational or administrative changes – relate to the day-to-day management of the activity within the boundaries of the existing policy approval from the Government. Examples are increases or decreases in cost recovery charges and forward estimates due to changes in costs or business processes, that ensures the Government decision for charge level is being delivered (full cost recovery or partial cost recovery). Changes to the legislation imposing cost recovery charges may be required. If entity staff are unsure whether the change is within the existing policy approval, they should consult the Department of Finance and the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet.
  • policy changes – involve variations to the approach to charging that are beyond the original policy approval for charging for the activity. Examples are moving from partial to full cost recovery, the provision of waivers and exemptions from cost recovery charges, or structural change in the activity, such as the adoption of a risk-based approach to regulation. These changes are likely to require new policy approval from the Government and amendments to the relevant legislation.

The treatment of changes also depends on their complexity, materiality and sensitivity. A risk assessment (using the CRA template for existing charging) can assist in assessment the likely impact of expected changes and to determine the approvals that may be required. For non-regulatory charges the template can offer areas of consideration when assessing the changed charges risk. Generally, where the risk rating is ‘high’, the changes are likely to be considered to be policy changes; where the rating is ‘low’ or 'medium', the changes are likely to be operational.

For operational changes to charges, relevant approvals should be provided by accountable authorities of entities and/or responsible Ministers for both regulatory and non-regulatory charges. Where required, legislation and internal processes should be amended.

Policy changes to charges will most likely require policy approval by the Government in accordance with the Budget Process Operational Rules. Entity staff should consult Finance and the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet about the processes and timeframes for submitting proposals to the Australian Government.

Regulatory activities CRIS must be kept up to date, so entity staff must amend it accordingly once the change is approved and make it publicly available before the change to cost recovery charges takes effect.

For further information regarding risk assessment, refer to: Risk engagement for regulatory activities, or Risk engagement for non-regulatory activities.