Completing the RPAT
On this page
The Risk Potential Assessment Tool (RPAT) template contains 21 mandatory questions – 7 relating to strategic context and 14 relating to implementation complexity.
The questions are designed to enable consistent consideration of risk sources at the pre Government decision stage, within a standard evidence based document.
Guidance to answer each question is provided below. Responses to questions must reflect pre-mitigation levels of risk and be developed in line with this guidance.
Each question in Section A and B is answered by entering 2 pieces of information:
- risk rating
- justification.
Risk rating
Link copiedEach question requires one choice from:
- very low
- low
- medium
- high
- very high.
A brief text prompt specific to each question is provided to guide the selection.
Justification
Link copiedThe justification field is used to state assumptions underpinning the selection of a Risk Rating for that question. Ensure text is succinct – approximately 250 characters is recommended.
Creating the top 5 risks table
Link copiedThe top 5 risks table will automatically populate from answers to the 21 questions.
The top 5 risks are ranked in order of individual question risk rating, for example, all the very highs are extracted first, then the highs and so on. Then, the order in which the extracted top 5 risks are presented is based on the question ordering (for example, Q1 will be presented before Q2 if both are very high).
| RISK | JUSTIFICATION | MITIGATION | RESIDUAL RISK |
|
#1 Government priority Very high |
This text is carried forward for the Justification fields in the RPAT question. | Mitigation text is entered directly here by the drafting entity. | Very High |
|
#2 Citizens Very high |
This text is carried forward from the Justification field in the RPAT question. | Mitigation text is entered directly here by the drafting entity. | HIgh |
|
#3 Stakeholders High |
This text is carried forward from the Justification field in the RPAT question. | Mitigation text is entered directly here by the drafting entity. | Medium |
|
#4 Information technology High |
This text is carried forward from the Justification field in the RPAT question. | Mitigation text is entered directly here by the drafting entity. | Medium |
|
#5 Financial impact Medium |
This text is carried forward from the Justification field in the RPAT question. | Mitigation text is entered directly here by the drafting entity. | Medium |
Adding mitigation and residual risk
Link copiedRisk mitigation is the process of developing options and actions to enhance opportunities and reduce threats to project objectives.
Once the top 5 risks table is populated, enter mitigation information into the table. If appropriate alter the Residual Risk rating, which may affect the overall risk (including mitigation) in the risk summary.
Mitigation, or the risk treatment, should be directly related to implementation risks which may arise assuming the proposal proceeds.
Although only the top 5 risks require mitigation actions to be entered in the RPAT, you must consider mitigation for all risks outlined in the RPAT. Consider the strengths and weaknesses of each mitigation action entered.
Residual risk
Link copiedResidual risk is the risk remaining after mitigation (risk treatment). The overall Risk (including mitigation) rating may be reduced after the mitigation is applied.
While some questions in the RPAT can have mitigation strategies leading to a lower risk rating, there are some categories where the risk rating will not reduce (for example, if the proposal is for a signature reform, which attracts a VERY HIGH risk rating for Government Priority, the residual risk can only be lowered if the Government Priority is lowered).
The detailed guidance for each question in the RPAT provides advice on risks unlikely to have a lower Residual Risk.
You must only lower the Residual Risk where there is evidence to suggest the options for treating the risk would lower the likelihood of it occurring.
Risk summary
Link copiedThe strategic context rating is determined by the answers to the questions in section A of the RPAT.
The implementation complexity rating is determined by the answers to the questions in section B of the RPAT.
The legal risk rating, if high, will affect the level of risk (before mitigation) and the overall risk (including mitigation) so that the minimum rating for these 2 indicators will be high.
The level of risk (before mitigation) is calculated by the intersection of strategic context and implementation complexity. This rating is highlighted and bolded in the risk summary table as it is the risk that is used to determine if Finance requires the completed RPAT.
Overall risk (including mitigation) is calculated from the potentially lowered residual risk ratings applied to the top 5 risks. The overall risk (including mitigation) will often not be different to the level of risk (before mitigation), as the RPAT form only has provision for 5 of the 21 questions to have their residual risks lowered.
Please note, Finance will consider the level of risk (before mitigation) in deciding whether to recommend assurance reviews for the proposal.
| The Risk Summary is calculated by the RPAT form. | |
| Strategic Context | Medium |
| Implementation Complexity | High |
| Legal Risk | Medium |
| Level of Risk (before mitigation) | High |
| Overall Risk (including mitigation) | Medium |
Answering the 21 mandatory questions
Link copiedQuestions A1 - A7
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| Very low government profile. | Moderate government interest. | Very high government interest/priority. |
Rate the strategic priority placed on this proposal by government. For example, is it an election commitment or significant reform? If you are unsure about the answer, consult your central entity contact.
Mitigation and residual risk
Mitigation strategies are unlikely to affect the Government’s priority. This typically only occurs if the Government changes their strategic priorities for the Budget. The residual risk usually remains the same as the pre-mitigation level of risk.
Risk treatment is unlikely to reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| Exposure of public funds, less than $50m. | Exposure of public funds $250-$500m. | Exposure of public funds greater than $1 billion. |
Indicate the level of cost and financial exposure associated with the proposal. In determining direct costs:
- give the total cost over the entire life of the program or project, including for any potential future comebacks (for example, pilot projects, proof of concepts, first pass business cases) using the gross cost estimate (do not adjust down for any offsets)
- include both administered and departmental costs over the forward estimates
- consider whether all costs have been considered
- include any contingent liabilities that may accrue to government as a result of implementation, and
- consider whether the proposal is likely to require additional funding.
Mitigation and residual risk
As these are estimates being put forward as part of the new policy proposal (NPP), it is not possible to change them through mitigation measures. The residual risk will usually be the same as the pre-mitigation level of risk.
Risk treatment is unlikely to reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| Low impact on small number of citizens. | Medium impact on moderate number of citizens. | Large impact on large number of citizens. |
Assess the level of impact on citizens, both in terms of number of citizens affected, or impact on groups of citizens. Citizens are defined as an Australian citizen or Australian resident. Consider the effect the proposal will have on citizens if fully delivered, partially delivered or if delivery fails. The text explanation should include which segments of the public will be affected and the degree to which each segment will be affected.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| Minimal impact on private sector. | Moderate negative or positive impact on private sector. | Significant negative or positive impact on private sector. |
Determine the effect on the private sector, or markets. Specify which sectors will be affected positively or negatively and the size of the effect on each sector. Consider the capacity of the private sector to take on any responsibilities associated with the proposal, the level of interest and opposition in the private sector as well as the size of the market in relation to government intervention.
Highlight and detail if there is an impact on the small to medium enterprise (SME) market.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| Straight forward stakeholder arrangement or no stakeholder opposition expected. | Multiple stakeholders or some stakeholder opposition expected. | Complex stakeholder arrangements or significant stakeholder opposition expected. |
Identify what issues exist in dealing with stakeholders for this proposal. Consider who the stakeholders are, identify what positions or expectations they may have in relation to the proposal and any complexities associated with stakeholder management. Include stakeholders represented through interest groups and/or the media.
When determining a strategic context stakeholder rating, consider:
- the complexity and number of stakeholder groups involved
- the diversity of views and how they may influence the proposal, and
- the potential consequences of stakeholder opposition.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| AGS legal risk ratings (where relevant) are Low, and contracting risk is very low. | AGS legal risk ratings (where relevant) are medium, or contracting may involve indemnities, warranties or guarantees. | AGS legal risk ratings (where relevant) are high, stakeholders are litigious, or contracting creates significant risks to the Commonwealth. |
Identify the legal issues which may impact policy design, or implementation of the proposal. Explain the legal risks which arise from:
- Australian Government Solicitor (AGS) advice
- contingent liabilities such as warranties, guarantees and indemnities
- personal injury or property damage arising from implementation
- a highly litigious stakeholder group.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating. Mitigation for the risks that arise in AGS advice can only reduce the residual risk rating in consultation with AGS.
| Very Low | Low | Med | High | Very High |
| Very Low other risk. | Medium other risk. | Proposal specific risk to be highlighted for Cabinet. |
Identify any other risk in the strategic context that isn’t already covered above and is specific to this type of policy. This section intends to alert Cabinet to significant issues not already captured in previous questions. Examples of risks that could be covered here are significant security, environmental, cyber, international and location constraints and/or issues. These are common risks that are not covered by a specific question in the RPAT and can have consequences for government.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
Questions B1 - B14
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| No other jurisdictions, entities or business units involved. | Some involvement across other jurisdictions, entities or business areas. | Complex involvement across jurisdictions, entities or business units. |
Assess the degree to which the proposal cuts across other jurisdictions, entities or business areas. Specify what involvement they have with the proposal and how this involvement may add complexity or difficulty to the implementation of the proposal.
If multiple entities are involved in delivering a proposal, it will typically attract a 'medium' or higher rating. Additionally, if the proposal includes any involvement with States or Territories, or has the potential for inter-governmental agreements, national partnership agreements or national Cabinet involvement, it would likely attract a high or very high rating.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very Low | Low | Med | High | Very High |
| Less than $50m. | $250m - $500m. | Greater than $1b. |
Indicate the size of the expected financial benefit to be derived from the proposal. Consider any additional revenue from the proposal, greater efficiencies, long-term reductions in costs or other benefits that are clearly identified and quantified in the proposal.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment is unlikely to reduce the level of risk.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| Limited impact on operations or staff. | Some organisational restructuring, retraining or transfer of staff/ outsourcing. | Very significant impact on operations or staff. Rectifying high profile operational failure. |
Determine what transformation or alterations to entity structure and practices/culture would be required to implement the proposal.
Proposals which require the establishment, merger or abolishment of an entity would likely attract a high or very high rating.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
|
Involves no new technology, development, methods, production or tools.
|
Involves new techniques with a stable application or known techniques with new application. | Use of new or untested technology, development, methods, production or tools with high degree of complexity or uncertainty. |
Determine how much innovation will be incorporated into the proposal. Assess the inherent risks in developing and delivering proposals that involve significant new or untested methods of practice/technology.
Consider what innovative tools or applications are to be used in the proposal, if this innovative approach has been previously used and, if so, whether the previous use was a success.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| No ICT component. | ICT infrastructure required, packaged software, data migration or some links to other internal/external systems. | Significant infrastructure requirements, complex data migration, or extensive and/or complex links to internal/external systems. |
Determine the level of complexity and structure of the proposed information and communications technology (ICT) and how this is incorporated into the proposal.
The examples provided in the risk rating boxes above are not exhaustive. Consider all other potential complexities associated with the ICT component within the proposal, this may include the technical skills and availability required to implement the proposed ICT.
Proposals subject to the ICT investment approval process would likely attract a high or very high rating for this question. Please include any Tiering assessment completed by Digital Transformation Agency (DTA) in the Justification field (tier 1, tier 2, or tier 3), plus any refence numbers provided by the DTA.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| No procurement. | Delivery of complex products/services. | Significant customised element. Multi-stage procurement process. |
Determine the extent of formal procurement or tendering envisaged for the proposal. The explanation should incorporate all related procurements and the complexity associated with each of the procurement processes proposed.
Particular attention should be given to:
- known instances where similar procurements have failed
- budget overruns
- instances where market capability has been unable to meet the procurement needs as specified.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| No construction requirements. | New construction using non-standard construction. | Unique Commonwealth construction or other construction with extensive customised elements. |
Determine the level and nature of construction in the proposal. Reflect all construction and the complexity associated for each construction proposed.
There are many aspects of construction which may add complexity, such as:
- heritage/architectural value
- proximity to environmentally fragile areas, endangered species and the like
- proximity to areas associated with indigenous culture/identity
- proposed usage for a highly sensitive activity.
Proposals subject to the Two Stage Capital Works Approval Process would likely attract a high or very high rating for this question. Please include in the justification field whether the NPP has been assessed as being subject to the Two Stage Capital Works process.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| No contract/ delivery arrangements required. |
Multiple suppliers but with single prime contractor. Separate service delivery entity. |
Complex commercial arrangements. Multiple suppliers without prime contractor or multiple service delivery partners. |
Determine the nature and level of commercial or service delivery arrangements associated with this proposal. The explanation should address how contracts or agreements for delivery are set up and the private sector or other delivery partner’s capacity to meet supply needs. Indicate the effect that contract and supply arrangements may have on the industry or service delivery segment. Please specify the type of contractual arrangement with the delivery partner, for example, contracts, grants, inter-governmental agreements, memorandums of understanding.
Where multiple suppliers or another Commonwealth entity is providing service delivery arrangements for the proposal, this is likely to attract a medium, high or very high rating. Early consultation with the service delivery entity should have taken place, and their input should be reflected in this assessment.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| Straight forward and stable governance structure. | Some governance issues identified and actions developed to correct them. | Complex governance structures likely to change during life of the project/ program. |
Determine the complexity of the governance arrangements for the proposal. Consider whether the structures involve cross-entity or interdepartmental committees, inter-jurisdictional governance arrangements or external representation in the governance arrangements.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| Fully resourced and skilled team and management. No recruitment requirement or specialist training. | Key skills/experience in place but recruitment or training required for staff. | Key skills/experience lacking or not available. Significant new resources or training required. |
Determine the resources currently allocated to, or available to implement the proposal. Consider the level of team and management experience for the proposal and whether this needs to be enhanced, difficulties that may arise in relation to recruitment or training, and any complexity associated with sourcing skills externally or internally.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| No challenge in meeting timetables. | Compressed or extended timeframe for delivery. | Difficult schedules, no contingency allowed. Uncontrolled changes to deadlines likely. |
Determine whether there are timing constraints which add complexity to the proposal (for example, fixed dates for the commencement of the proposal) and how these constraints could impact delivery of the proposal on time, on budget and to expectations.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| No dependence on the success/delivery of other projects/programs. | Some dependence on the successful delivery of other projects/programs. | Fully dependent on the successful delivery of other projects/programs. |
Assess the levels of dependence or interdependence between this proposal and other projects/programs for successful implementation. Consider the nature of the other projects/programs that this proposal is dependent on, the status of these projects/programs and the level of dependence.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| The policy intent is clear and policy development has a high level of assurance. | Clarity of the policy is developing and policy development has some level of assurance. | Policy lacks clarity and policy development has low level of assurance. |
Determine how well-developed and understood the policy intent for the proposal is. Consider the level of policy development that is planned, the level of detail or direction given by Government for the proposal, and whether all parties are committed and have a common understanding of the proposal’s intent. For example, states and territories, or if industry input is envisaged for final program design.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the level of risk.
| Very low | Low | Med | High | Very high |
| Entity has extensive experience with producing comparable outputs. | Entity has experience with comparable projects but the proposal presents new complexities for delivery. | Entity has no previous experience with this kind of proposal. |
Determine how proficient/experienced the entity is in delivering this type of proposal. Consider the capability demonstrated in the delivery of similar outputs by the entity, if the entity has retained relevant capabilities and what lessons have been learned from previous initiatives.
Consideration should be given to:
- outcomes from recent entity capability reviews
- capability improvement strategies
- outcomes from recent independent assurance reviews such as Gateway
- workforce planning and the impact on the entity implementing the proposal
- whether the implementation of the policy initiative is managed by an entity as “business as usual” or using project management disciplines
- the implications this initiative will have for the entity’s workforce (capacity, capability, location, functional alignment to business delivery)
- the new skills or capabilities that will become important to achieve business outcomes and how will they be acquired (developed internally or attracted from external sources)
- the current availability of these new skills and capabilities in the external labour market and, the level of impact if they are not available at critical time points in the implementation
- the skills and capabilities that will no longer be required and how this surplus will be managed.
Mitigation and residual risk
Risk treatment may reduce the risk rating.