Competitive Appointment Processes

If ministers do not express a view on reappointment, or do not support reappointing an existing board member, portfolio departments and Finance start a competitive appointment process 6–8 months before the term expires.

This timing allows for a robust process and ensures recommendations are provided to ministers around 2–3 months before the expiry date.

A joint search process may be used when 2 or more board member terms are due to expire within a few months of each other.

The Chair should discuss with Portfolio departments and Finance whether an external executive search provider should be engaged by the SIV or Portfolio departments and Finance or jointly. An external executive search provider is expected to enhance contestability, gain market insights and increase the independence of the appointment process. 
Advertising can be added to an executive search process, at the request of Ministers or, if departments and Chair agree, subject to ministerial approval. If used, advertising signposts an opportunity and other means of attracting candidates must also be used. Advertising can occur online or in a suitable national publication and incurs costs on top of the search process.

Appropriate due diligence should be undertaken as well as assessing candidates against skills matrices. This may include full education, corporate and forensic social media and bankruptcy background checks. Candidate capabilities, experience and interest should also be assessed, referencing the existing and future needs of the SIV and consideration of any pre-existing conflicts of interest.

Recommendations for appointments should be on the basis of merit, balancing the candidate's individual capacity to contribute to the board and the relevant skills mix required for the board to fulfil its objectives.

A suggested appointment process for portfolio departments and Finance is provided below. This process is not exhaustive and acts as a guide only.

Reappointments

Considering reappointments during an appointment process.

It may be appropriate to consider recommending that an existing board member be reappointed or extended to ensure board continuity, stability and knowledge retention. To inform this decision portfolio departments and Finance should consider the following:

  • the overall board and the member’s performance during their term informed by performance evaluations (independent and internally conducted)
  • the member’s skills, specialist expertise, characteristics and reputation to determine if they are relevant for the next 2-5 years (depending on board term), including:
    • the current status of all declared conflicts of interest with an up-to-date PID form and curriculum vitae (CV)
    • sub-committee requirements and upcoming strategic activities.
  • the need for board continuity, balanced with the need for turnover
  • diversity requirements and any diversity gaps of the board
  • the length of time the member has served on the board, relevant term limits established by enabling legislation and best practice corporate governance
  • any feedback from the Chair.

The existing board member may be asked to attend an assessment interview or meeting and may be required to re-apply for their role on the board if an application process is being conducted.

An open advertised or search process may also be conducted, and the existing member may wish to be considered for reappointment as part of this process against the selection criteria and other candidates considered as suitable for the role. 

Board succession planning

Succession planning is critical for ensuring appointment of high performing boards.

Portfolio departments, in consultation with Finance should be proactive in board succession planning. To be proactive, departments, with the Chairs, should monitor upcoming board member vacancies and develop a plan by referencing the board information pack for filling any vacant position. This should occur at least 6-12 months ahead of expiry to avoid having to meet the skill requirements of the board on short notice. Good succession planning should consider:

  • the present composition of the board and upcoming term vacancies
  • internal and external board performance reviews
  • the performance of the SIV
  • each member’s skills (both depth and breadth) and capabilities
  • whether there are members with chair and facilitation capabilities and skills to chair any committees
  • the qualities and skills the SIV need to deliver the government-set objectives and to address any changing future strategic and operational needs, including industry experience, professional qualifications and personal qualities.

Succession planning should include succession for the Chair. Future chair candidates should be identified as early as possible and could include candidates from within the existing board.

Where terms of multiple board members are expiring in close succession, portfolio departments and Finance should consider whether mitigation strategies against loss of corporate knowledge should be employed to ensure board continuity. This could include:

  • short term extensions
  • varying the member(s) term of appointment within the maximum legislated term length
  • considering the case for reappointing current members.

Induction and training

SIVs should develop comprehensive training for board members to effectively fulfil their duties.

SIVs are responsible for developing and maintaining appropriate induction and onboarding training for board members, with support from portfolio departments and Finance as necessary. New board members should take part in a well-structured induction program. Induction programs are expected to incorporate, at a minimum, the SIV’s governance policies and legal obligations, including those unique to Commonwealth entities such as under the PGPA Act and other legislation.

Training should not be limited to the induction process. SIVs and their boards are expected to identify relevant training and briefing needs on an ongoing basis and arrange appropriate refresher briefings and training periodically. 

Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Appointments

Ensuring the integrity of CEO appointments.

SIV boards are generally responsible for appointing CEOs, which under the enabling legislation may require the Chair consults with the responsible minister(s) and in some cases the Finance Minister. It is advised that even where not required in enabling legislation the Chair should provide responsible minister(s) and Finance Minister with the opportunity to discuss the CEO appointment.

CEO appointments are considered significant government appointments and are expected to be conducted in line with requirements outlined in the Cabinet Handbook. This includes providing Cabinet with sufficient time to consider the proposed appointment. Formally appointing a CEO should not occur until Cabinet has the opportunity to consider the proposed appointment and notified the Chair that this has occurred.

The CEO is directly accountable to the board. Potential CEO candidates should be identified through a public advertising and/or executive search process. CEO appointments should be based on professional criteria that considers the needs of the SIV and the requirements set in legislation, as relevant.

Where a CEO appointment term is not defined in enabling legislation, SIV boards should consider appointments on a fixed term basis (generally of 3 to 5 years) with the flexibility for reappointment based on performance and strategic alignment. Fixed terms provide boards with the flexibility to assess leadership needs at a known point in time and make changes based on shifts in the business environment or strategic direction. They also support forward planning, transparency and accountability.