Regulator Maturity Model Self-Assessment Tool
On this page
The Regulator Maturity Self-Assessment Tool was developed by the Department of Finance to help regulators evaluate and improve their regulatory capability at the enterprise level. The self-assessment aligns to the 12 capability domains covered in the Regulator Maturity Model.
Regulator Maturity Model Self-Assessment tool [XLSX, 146Kb]
The tool helps regulators to identify strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities for improvement. It supports strategic planning and enables regulators to track changes in capability over time, including comparison with previous self-assessments.
Before starting
Link copiedRegulators should be familiar with the Regulator Maturity Model and Self-Assessment User Guide before using the tool. The tool is an interactive document structured across 8 tabs.
- Tab 1 asks questions about the regulator’s circumstances, such as size.
- Tabs 2 to 7 ask questions covering the capability domains in the Regulator Maturity Model.
- Tab 8 summarises the regulator’s self-assessment ratings.
The assessment can take up to 6 weeks to complete in full.
The self-assessment process
Link copiedStep 1: Decide on the scope of the self-assessment and who needs to be involved
Although the model and tool are designed for use at the enterprise level, regulators may choose to assess a single regulatory function within a department or a specific area within a regulator.
Regardless of the approach, it is helpful to assign responsibility to one person or team to coordinate the self-assessment. Involving staff from different internal teams can provide a wider range of perspectives and strengthen the assessment.
Regulators should consider which areas within the entity or regulatory function can help answer the questions. This may include teams with relevant subject matter expertise. Collaboration across multiple teams, branches or divisions may be required.
Colleagues from outside the entity or regulatory function may also be involved. This could include staff from another regulator with an established working relationship or another regulatory function within the same department.
External perspectives can help reduce positivity bias and improve the quality of the self-assessment.
Step 2. Gather supporting information needed to answer the self-assessment questions
Additional information may be needed to answer some questions. For example, some questions ask about whether an entity or regulatory function has acted on results from other Commonwealth maturity frameworks to improve regulatory practices.
Other information may include internal documents about education, compliance and enforcement policies or strategies. It may also include information about tools, processes or systems used within the entity or regulatory function.
Regulators should consider examples to support their responses. This approach helps identify appropriate assessment ratings and highlights areas that may require further action.
Examples may include:
- actions taken and how frequently they occur
- whether actions apply across all levels or areas of the entity or regulatory function
- processes in place to ensure actions are implemented
- how often actions or arrangements are reviewed and updated
- who is engaged, and how and when engagement occurs
- evaluation processes used to measure success, including international evaluation processes where relevant
- how often processes, strategies or risk-based planning or targeting for your activities are reviewed, such as annually, quarterly or monthly
- actions taken to address gaps in regulatory systems or processes
- tools or resources used, including those of other regulators, other Australian Government frameworks or maturity models, or other jurisdictions.
The tool includes space to make notes or explain context for responses. This may include examples that support a rating, reasons why a question cannot be answered, or examples of successful practices.
Do not include any information in the tool that is commercially sensitive, protected from disclosure by Commonwealth law, or includes personally identifiable information.
Step 3: Answer the self-assessment questions and determine maturity ratings
The tool is interactive and uses drop down lists for responses. Each response aligns with one of the 4 maturity levels. If a question cannot be answered, the option “does not apply / unable to answer / assess” can be selected.
The self-assessment process involves the following steps:
- Step 1. Answer all questions for each capability domain. The tool will record a maturity level rating for each question based on the answer selected.
- Step 2. Select an overall maturity level rating for the capability domain that best reflects where most of the results align.
- Step 3. Repeat these steps for each capability domain across tabs 2 to 7.
After all questions have been answered, an overall maturity rating for the entity or regulatory function should be selected on tab 8.
Regulators are expected to use their best judgement when selecting maturity ratings. If results span more than one maturity level, the rating that reflects most of the results should be selected. For example, if a capability domain includes four ratings of ‘embedded’ and one rating of ‘developing’, the overall rating for that domain would be ‘embedded’.
Step 4: Share results with the Department of Finance
Once the self-assessment is complete, the self-assessment should be cleared by an appropriate SES officer for the entity or function.
Once cleared, results should be shared with the Department of Finance at regulatorcapability@finance.gov.au.
Finance will treat all information as confidential. Identified information about a regulator will not be shared with other regulators or departments.
Using the self-assessment results
Link copiedAfter completing the self-assessment, regulators will have a baseline maturity snapshot.
Next steps include:
- analysing the results and setting priorities for each maturity domain
- developing a Maturity Action Plan that outlines actions, resources, responsibilities and timelines
- scheduling regular reviews of the Maturity Action Plan and planning the next self-assessment to track progress over time.
Maturity action plans
Based on the assessment results, regulators should identify:
- the top 2 - 3 priorities for each capability domain, including why each priority has been identified
- actions required to address each priority and the resources needed
- who is responsible for each action
- target completion dates for each action.