Avenues for dispute resolution
On this page
Overview
Link copiedIf parties cannot agree on compensation, several resolution options may be available. These include valuers’ conferences, alternative dispute resolution, mediation, review by the Administrative Review Tribunal, and determination by the Federal Court.
Valuers’ conference
Link copiedA valuers’ conference is a formal meeting between the Commonwealth, the landholder and their respective valuers where there is disagreement on the valuation or methodology.
Before conducting a valuers’ conference it may be beneficial for the parties to narrow down the areas of dispute as much as possible. Alternative dispute resolution such as pre-conference discussions between the relevant parties may be an effective tool to support this.
While either party may request a valuers’ conference, the Commonwealth may wish to consider offering a conference to the landholder as a proactive alternative to dispute resolution.
It is the Commonwealth’s responsibility to keep negotiations progressing effectively and to use appropriate valuations to inform offers as part of the negotiation or claims process.
See Valuation for more information.
Alternative dispute resolution
Link copiedIf an acquisition by agreement was initiated by a PAD or section 24 certificate, and the parties cannot agree on terms or price, officials should consider using alternative dispute resolution before moving to compulsory acquisition. This may include using an independent third party to evaluate or mediate the matter.
See Stakeholder engagement for more information.
Mediation
Link copiedMediation can be a beneficial process to assist parties to negotiate a mutually agreeable outcome. It can be more flexible, efficient and less costly than litigation.
Mediation in the context of a claim for compensation under the Lands Acquisition Act 1989 (LAA) following compulsory acquisition may occur either before or after an offer of compensation has been made by the Finance Minister.
While there is no requirement under the LAA to offer mediation when the parties do not agree on the amount of compensation, under a compulsory acquisition process the Finance Minister and a person who has rejected an offer (including a final offer of compensation) may agree to refer the question of the amount of compensation to be determined by an expert or settled by an arbitrator.
Any agreement at mediation in relation to a claim for compensation following compulsory acquisition will still need to be reflected in the decision-making processes and formal steps provided for under the LAA in terms of the making and acceptance of offers of compensation.
Administrative Review Tribunal
Link copiedSection 81 of the LAA provides that if a final offer of compensation by the Finance Minister is rejected by a claimant, then the claimant can seek a review of the Finance Minister’s decision in the Administrative Review Tribunal.
In reviewing the decision, the Administrative Review Tribunal may exercise all the powers and discretions conferred by the LAA on the Finance Minister in making the final offer and can decide to affirm or vary the final offer of compensation made by the Finance Minister.
Federal Court of Australia
Link copiedSection 82 of the LAA provides for determination of the amount of compensation by the Federal Court, where a person has made a claim for compensation, or the Finance Minister has made an offer of compensation under section 74A of the LAA.
A claimant, or the Commonwealth may institute proceedings in the Federal Court for a determination of the amount of compensation to which the person is entitled.
The Commonwealth cannot institute proceedings in the Federal Court seeking a determination of compensation until at least 3 months after the making of a claim or the offer of compensation under section 74A.
See Stakeholder engagement for more information.
Policies, legislation and guidelines
Link copied- The Constitution
- Auditor-General Act 1997
- Public Service Act 1999
- Crimes Act 1914
- Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013
- Lands Acquisition Act 1989
- Lands Acquisition Act 1955 (for preserved mining provisions)
- Lands Acquisition Regulations 2017
- Lands Acquisition 1989 Delegation Instrument
- Commonwealth Property Disposal Policy
Resource Management Guides
Link copiedTools and templates
Link copiedGlossary
Link copied- Accountable Authorities
- Assigning a lease
- Australian Government Property Register (AGPR)
- Budget Process Operational Rules
- Budget Process Operational Rules (BPORs)
- Capital Management Plan (CMP)
- Capital Works
- Chief Financial Officer (CFO)
- Commonwealth authority
- Commonwealth National Lease (CNL)
- Commonwealth Procurement Rules (CPRs)
- Contract Notice (CN)
- Corporate Commonwealth entity
- Cost Benefit Analysis
- Department of Defence (Defence)
- Department of Finance (Finance)
- Detailed Business Case (DBC)
- Embodied Emissions
- Entity
- Expediency motion
- Fit-out
- Goods and Services Tax (GST)
- Greenhouse Gas (GHG)
- Heads of compensation
- Initial Business Case (IBC)
- Landholder
- Lands Acquisition Act 1989 (LAA)
- Lease
- Lease Endorsement
- Lease Notification
- Leasing Strategy
- Local Impact Assessment
- Memorandum of Understanding (MoU)
- New Policy Proposal (NPP)
- Non-corporate Commonwealth entity
- Occupational Density Target
- Official
- P50 / P80
- Parliamentary Standing Committee on Public Works/Public Works Committee (PWC)
- Property
- Property Management Plan (PMP)
- Property Operating Expenses (POE)
- Property Service Provider (PSP)
- Property Services Coordinated Procurement (PSCP) Arrangements
- Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (PGPA Act)
- Public Works
- Public Works Committee Act 1969 (PWC Act)
- Real Property
- Referral motion
- Resource Management Guide (RMG)
- Statistical Area level 2 (SA2)
- Strategic Property Adviser (SPA)
- Surrendering a lease
- Two Stage Capital Works Approval Process
- Value for money
- Whole of Government Leasing Strategy (Leasing strategy)
- Whole-of-Life Costs (WoLC)
- Work Package
- Work-point