3-step commercial assessment
On this page
Part 1 - Investment proposal and business case development of the Commonwealth Investments Resource Management Guide supports Commonwealth entities to prepare a detailed business case to support all investment proposals, including a detailed assessment of commercial models and financing approaches.
This 3-step commercial assessment aims to provide a process for the identification and selection of opportunities, commercial constructs, financing, and risk/reward sharing models.
Is the proposal clear on government's objectives - what are the key factors and trade-offs that affect the efficiency and effectiveness of this investment?
Consider the project dimensions that affect:
Effectiveness - for example:
- key scope requirements
- accessibility requirements
- quality, reliability and other standards
- consequences of not meeting policy outcomes.
Efficiency - for example:
- importance and sensitivity of timelines
- major drivers for upfront/ongoing costs
- interdependencies between upfront and ongoing costs
- capabilities required to deliver and manage the project.
-
Are there options to appropriately involve private sector capability or capital, or both, to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the investment?
- At face value, is the subject matter appropriate for private partnership?
- Does the partnership model optimise the efficiency and effectiveness of private sector involvement and appropriately balance risk?
- Are there sufficient providers willing and able to compete?
- Does the proposed market engagement process ensure that the right balance of private sector participants are engaged?
- Do the identified potential partnership options provide government an opportunity to consider key trade-offs?
- What are the potential financial structures for government's interest - considering:
- the need for control/oversight
- optimal balance of risk exposure and potential reward
- opportunity and actual cost of various forms of financing.
- What are the options for different entities and stakeholders to govern the project - including decision-rights, processes and structures?
- Do the identified options for public sector involvement provide government a meaningful, informed choice on key trade-offs?
The 3-step commercial assessment can be used to guide which government projects are both appropriate and suitable for private sector investment and inform the development, design and evaluation of potential partnership and financing models for government consideration at first pass and will assist with further refinements before second pass consideration.
Overview
Link copiedThis 3-step commercial assessment provides a checklist that entities are to consider as part of investment proposal and business case development. This tool is used to guide the selection and evaluation of projects and to ensure they provide:
- clarity on government’s objectives and key factors and trade-offs that may affect the efficiency and effectiveness of the investment
- options considered to appropriately involve private sector capability and/or capital to improve efficiency and effectiveness of the investment and
- a proposal on how government’s interest is best structured and managed to serve government’s objectives when government is directly involved inexecution of the investment and/or ownership of the resultant asset.
While the 3-step commercial assessment tool generally progresses sequentially, the process can be iterative and partnership models in particular may require revision and adjustment if they do not allow for optimal financing solutions.
Projects can then commence detailed design, approvals and go-to-market process suited to the underlying asset and portfolio (for example, governed by the Commonwealth Procurement Rules).
Investment instruments
Link copiedNon-grant financing using the right investment instrument can provide benefits to the government including increased involvement in project delivery decision-making, the opportunity to build and recycle capital and the opportunity to better allocate risk between parties.
Characteristics of investment instruments
There are a number of considerations to be balanced in determining the most appropriate non-grant financing option (or blend of options). The pros and cons outlined for each option listed below are assessed from the perspective of the government taking the role as investor.
The stated policy objectives of the project or program will help guide which considerations carry the greatest weight.
| Investment instrument | Equity injection part-ownership |
Equity injection 100% ownership by holder of instrument |
Guarantee | Commercial loan market gap finance |
Concessional loan | Convertible insrument (bought by government) |
Derivative issued by government |
|
Ability to influence financed objective Ability for the holder of instrument to provide direction in relation to the investment |
Medium control | High control | Low control | Medium control - depends on loan conditions | Medium control - depends on loan conditions | Medium-high control - depends on if equity feature is exercised | Medium-high control - depends on whether the derivative is traded on an exchange and the nature of the derivative. |
|
Level of market intervention The significance of the intervention in the market and how determinative the instrument will be on future market conditions
|
Medium intervention | High intervention | Low-medium intervention - depends on the value of the risk guaranteed | Medium intervention | Medium intervention | Medium-high intervention | Low-high intervention - depends on the nature of the derivative |
|
Commercial discipline incentive The financial discipline achieved through the structure of the investment |
Low-medium incentive | Low-medium incentive | Low incentive | High incentive | Medium-high incentive | High incentive | Medium incentive |
|
Certainty of financial return Probability of the investment making a financial return |
Low certainty | Low certainty | Nil or high certainty (if fee charged) | High certainty | High certainty | Low-high certainty – depends on if equity feature is exercised | Nil-low certainty – depends on whether derivative is exercised and recoverability of upfront cost of derivative. |
|
Opportunity to realise upside gain The ability for the financier to benefit from over performance |
Medium-high capacity | High capacity | Nil capacity | Nil capacity | Nil capacity | High capacity | Nil-high capacity – depends on market state relative to nature of the derivative. |
|
Level of financial risk The potential loss of the investment instrument |
High risk | High risk | Medium risk | Medium risk | Medium risk | Medium-high risk – depends on if equity feature is exercised | Low-high risk – depends on nature of derivative, whether derivative is exercised and recoverability of derivative’s upfront cost. |
|
Security of asset The reduction of financial risk that can be achieved through the ability to structure the instruments. |
Low security | Low security | Nil security | High security | High security | Medium security | Nil security |
|
Administration cost Governance and management costs of the investment |
High administration | High administration | Low administration however medium-high if called | Medium administration | Medium administration | Medium-high – depends on if equity feature is exercised | Medium administration |
Involves the government taking an ownership interest in an entity in anticipation of future financial returns. Having the government as an equity partner can reduce costs and risks for private investors. Alternatively, the government may be the sole owner at the early stages of greenfield projects but bring in private investment once a project is more mature and less risky. In general, equity investment requires that the government has a higher tolerance for risk and making a loss than other investments like loans. For example, the government provided Western Sydney Airport (WSA Co) equity in exchange for ordinary shares. WSA Co only has fully paid ordinary shares in issue, all of which are owned by the Commonwealth.
Supports projects and priorities as a debt partner until projects are sufficiently developed to be wholly supported by private sector financing. Government debt financing is generally used to bridge a commercial market finance gap. For example, the government provided a loan on commercial terms to NBN Co so it could focus on the remaining rollout as it significantly scaled up toward completion in 2020.
Involves the government taking on financial obligations if certain risks eventuate. Government guarantees reduce the risk to private sector partners and can strengthen a project’s credit profile to attract private sector financing instead of government financing. For example, the government provides guarantees through the Accommodation Payment Guarantee Scheme for the repayment of aged care residents’ refundable accommodation payments if the approved provider becomes insolvent or bankrupt and defaults on its refund obligations.
Can be provided when a proposal is expected to generate some financial return, but private financing is either unavailable or unaffordable. Features of concessional loans include more favourable terms than terms offered by private debt markets. For example, the Commonwealth provides a concessional loan facility to a company wholly owned by the Sydney Motorway Corporation to finance a motorway.
Are hybrid financial instruments that contain debt and equity features. The debt feature yields fixed-interest payments, and the equity feature provides the holder of the convertible the right but not the obligation to convert the convertible into a predetermined number of shares.
A contract whose value is based on an underlying financial asset, index or security. Derivatives can be traded privately (over-the-counter) or on an exchange. A derivative facilitates the ability for government to influence strategic delivery of policy objectives as well as provides hedging on government initiatives exposed to market risks.
Budget classification
In addition to guidance provided in RMG 117 General principles for the recognition of expenditure in budget aggregates, the below table sets out the implications different investments instruments have on key Budget aggregates.
Note - the PDI impacts are reported as a consolidated line item at the whole-of-government level.
| Statements | Cash Flow Statement | Operating Statement | Balance Sheet | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Underlying cash balance | Headline cash balance | Net operating balance | Fiscal balance | Net debt | Net financial | |
| Equity | Initial | |||||
| No impact | Worsens by value of equity injection | No impact | No impact | Worsens by value of equity injection | No impact | |
| Ongoing | ||||||
| Dividend improves PDI worsens |
Dividend improves PDI worsens Sale improves |
Dividend improves PDI worsens |
Dividend improves PDI worsens |
Depends on differential between PDI and dividends | Depends on valuation of equity and differential between PDI and dividends | |
| Guarantee (Contractual) |
Initial | |||||
| No impact on establishment. Only if not probable it will be called | No impact on establishment. Only if not probable it will be called | Worsens as recognise obligation to pay | Worsens as recognise obligation to pay | No impact | Worsens as recognise obligation to pay | |
| Ongoing | ||||||
| Worsens if guarantee is exercised | Worsens if guarantee is exercised | No impact (assume value of guarantee remains constant). Improves after guarantee expires. | No impact (assume value of guarantee remains constant). Improves after guarantee expires. | Worsens if guarantee is exercised | Improves after guarantee expires | |
| *Contact the Department of Finance for more information on impacts from legislative guarantees | ||||||
| Commercial Loan (Market Gap Finance) |
Initial | |||||
| No impact | Worsens by value of principal payment | No impact | No impact | No impact | No impact | |
| Ongoing | ||||||
| Improves by differential between interest and PDI | Improves by differential between interest and PDI, and principal repayments | Improves by differential between interest and PDI | Improves by differential between interest and PDI | Improves by the differential between interest and PDI (assuming no revaluation) | ||
| Concessional Loan | Initial | |||||
| No impact | Worsens by value of principal payment | Worsens by value of concession (which is unwound) | Worsens by value of concession (which is unwound) | Worsens by value of concession | Worsens by value of concession | |
| Ongoing | ||||||
| Interest improves PDI worsens |
Interest improves PDI worsens Principal repayments improves |
Interest improves PDI worsens Value of concession unwinds over course of the loan |
Interest improves PDI worsens Value of concession unwinds over course of the loan |
Improves/worsens depending on differential between interest and PDI (assuming no revaluation) | ||
| Convertible Instrument (bought by Government) |
Initial | |||||
| No impact | Worsens by issuance price of the convertible | No impact | No impact | Worsens by value of equity component | No impact | |
| Ongoing | ||||||
| For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI For preference shares, dividend improves |
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI For preference shares, dividend improves |
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI For preference shares, dividend improves |
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI For preference shares, dividend improves |
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI For preference shares, depends on differential between PDI and dividends |
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI For preference shares, depends on valuation and differential between PDI and dividends |
|
| Derivative issued by Government |
Initial | |||||
| No impact | Worsens by value of derivative | No impact | No impact | No impact | No impact | |
| Ongoing | ||||||
| PDI worsens | PDI worsens Sale of derivative improves |
PDI worsens | PDI worsens | No impact | No impact | |