This 3-step commercial assessment aims to provide a process for the identification and selection of opportunities, commercial constructs, financing, and risk/reward sharing models.

Is the proposal clear on government's objectives - what are the key factors and trade-offs that affect the efficiency and effectiveness of this investment?

Consider the project dimensions that affect:

Effectiveness - for example:

  • key scope requirements
  • accessibility requirements
  • quality, reliability and other standards
  • consequences of not meeting policy outcomes.

Efficiency - for example:

  • importance and sensitivity of timelines
  • major drivers for upfront/ongoing costs
  • interdependencies between upfront and ongoing costs
  • capabilities required to deliver and manage the project.

 

  • Are there options to appropriately involve private sector capability or capital, or both, to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the investment?
  • At face value, is the subject matter appropriate for private partnership?
  • Does the partnership model optimise the efficiency and effectiveness of private sector involvement and appropriately balance risk?
  • Are there sufficient providers willing and able to compete?
  • Does the proposed market engagement process ensure that the right balance of private sector participants are engaged?
  • Do the identified potential partnership options provide government an opportunity to consider key trade-offs?
Where the public sector will be directly involved in execution of the investment or ownership of the resultant asset, or both, how is this involvement best structured and managed to serve government's objectives?
  • What are the potential financial structures for government's interest - considering:
    • the need for control/oversight
    • optimal balance of risk exposure and potential reward
    • opportunity and actual cost of various forms of financing.
  • What are the options for different entities and stakeholders to govern the project - including decision-rights, processes and structures?
  • Do the identified options for public sector involvement provide government a meaningful, informed choice on key trade-offs?

The 3-step commercial assessment can be used to guide which government projects are both appropriate and suitable for private sector investment and inform the development, design and evaluation of potential partnership and financing models for government consideration at first pass and will assist with further refinements before second pass consideration.

Involves the government taking an ownership interest in an entity in anticipation of future financial returns. Having the government as an equity partner can reduce costs and risks for private investors. Alternatively, the government may be the sole owner at the early stages of greenfield projects but bring in private investment once a project is more mature and less risky. In general, equity investment requires that the government has a higher tolerance for risk and making a loss than other investments like loans. For example, the government provided Western Sydney Airport (WSA Co) equity in exchange for ordinary shares. WSA Co only has fully paid ordinary shares in issue, all of which are owned by the Commonwealth.

Supports projects and priorities as a debt partner until projects are sufficiently developed to be wholly supported by private sector financing. Government debt financing is generally used to bridge a commercial market finance gap. For example, the government provided a loan on commercial terms to NBN Co so it could focus on the remaining rollout as it significantly scaled up toward completion in 2020.

Involves the government taking on financial obligations if certain risks eventuate. Government guarantees reduce the risk to private sector partners and can strengthen a project’s credit profile to attract private sector financing instead of government financing. For example, the government provides guarantees through the Accommodation Payment Guarantee Scheme for the repayment of aged care residents’ refundable accommodation payments if the approved provider becomes insolvent or bankrupt and defaults on its refund obligations.

Can be provided when a proposal is expected to generate some financial return, but private financing is either unavailable or unaffordable. Features of concessional loans include more favourable terms than terms offered by private debt markets. For example, the Commonwealth provides a concessional loan facility to a company wholly owned by the Sydney Motorway Corporation to finance a motorway.

Are hybrid financial instruments that contain debt and equity features. The debt feature yields fixed-interest payments, and the equity feature provides the holder of the convertible the right but not the obligation to convert the convertible into a predetermined number of shares.

A contract whose value is based on an underlying financial asset, index or security. Derivatives can be traded privately (over-the-counter) or on an exchange. A derivative facilitates the ability for government to influence strategic delivery of policy objectives as well as provides hedging on government initiatives exposed to market risks.

Budget classification

In addition to guidance provided in RMG 117 General principles for the recognition of expenditure in budget aggregates, the below table sets out the implications different investments instruments have on key Budget aggregates. 

Note - the PDI impacts are reported as a consolidated line item at the whole-of-government level.

Statements Cash Flow Statement Operating Statement Balance Sheet
Underlying cash balance Headline cash balance Net operating balance Fiscal balance Net debt Net financial
Equity Initial
No impact Worsens by value of equity injection No impact No impact Worsens by value of equity injection No impact
Ongoing
Dividend improves

PDI worsens
Dividend improves

PDI worsens

Sale improves
Dividend improves

PDI worsens
Dividend improves

PDI worsens
Depends on differential between PDI and dividends Depends on valuation of equity and differential between PDI and dividends
Guarantee
(Contractual)
Initial
No impact on establishment. Only if not probable it will be called No impact on establishment. Only if not probable it will be called Worsens as recognise obligation to pay Worsens as recognise obligation to pay No impact Worsens as recognise obligation to pay
Ongoing
Worsens if guarantee is exercised Worsens if guarantee is exercised No impact (assume value of guarantee remains constant). Improves after guarantee expires. No impact (assume value of guarantee remains constant). Improves after guarantee expires. Worsens if guarantee is exercised Improves after guarantee expires
*Contact the Department of Finance for more information on impacts from legislative guarantees
Commercial Loan
(Market Gap Finance)
Initial
No impact Worsens by value of principal payment No impact No impact No impact No impact
Ongoing
Improves by differential between interest and PDI Improves by differential between interest and PDI, and principal repayments Improves by differential between interest and PDI Improves by differential between interest and PDI Improves by the differential between interest and PDI (assuming no revaluation)
Concessional Loan Initial
No impact Worsens by value of principal payment Worsens by value of concession (which is unwound) Worsens by value of concession (which is unwound) Worsens by value of concession Worsens by value of concession
Ongoing
Interest improves
PDI worsens
Interest improves
PDI worsens

Principal repayments improves
Interest improves
PDI worsens

Value of concession unwinds over course of the loan
Interest improves
PDI worsens

Value of concession unwinds over course of the loan
Improves/worsens depending on differential between interest and PDI (assuming no revaluation)
Convertible Instrument
(bought by Government)
Initial
No impact Worsens by issuance price of the convertible No impact No impact Worsens by value of equity component No impact
Ongoing
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI

For preference shares, dividend improves
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI

For preference shares, dividend improves
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI

For preference shares, dividend improves
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI

For preference shares, dividend improves
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI

For preference shares, depends on differential between PDI and dividends
For the debt component of the convertible, improves by the differential between interest and PDI

For preference shares, depends on valuation and differential between PDI and dividends
Derivative issued
by Government
Initial
No impact Worsens by value of derivative No impact No impact No impact No impact
Ongoing
PDI worsens PDI worsens
Sale of derivative improves
PDI worsens PDI worsens No impact No impact