Commercial models
On this page
This toolkit item relates to Part 1 - Investment proposal and business case development of the Commonwealth Investments Resource Management Guide.
Commercial models summary
Link copiedExhibit 1 sets out commercial models that entities can consider when designing and evaluating ownership and partnership options with private sector. These commercial models are illustrative examples of potential options and are not exhaustive.
Exhibit 1: Summary of commercial models
| Conceptual ownership categories | Structure types | Roles for government | Levers to add value | |
| Key focus | Type of public and private involvement | Partnership types | Balance sheet impact | Nature of private sector value creation |
| Useful for | Considering the overall categories of investment | Developing detailed structures to suit particular investments | Considering government’s role in investments | Testing potential for private sector collaboration |
|
Key choices
|
|
|
|
|
Conceptual ownership categories from fully public to fully private
Link copiedAs a high-level conceptual map, entities can consider 5 ownership models on a spectrum from fully public to fully private, refer Exhibit 2.
The summary on the advantages and limitations for each model can be used as a guide to assess the most suitable models for the project or investment being evaluated.
The key principles and design considerations in each step of the Commonwealth Investment Framework will further guide selection of the most appropriate model, noting there are many levers available to adapt each of these high-level models.
Exhibit 2: Conceptual ownership categories from fully public to fully private
| Publicly owned and operated | Publicly owned Privately delivered/ operated |
Public and private co-ownership | Privately owned delivery of regulated public services | Purely private businesses | |
| Description | Investments in assets to support critical public services | Government finances and owns the underlying asset but contractors design, build and/or operate it under a contract (risks should be appropriately balanced) | Government and private sector each invest debt and/or equity in a project and appropriately share ownership, risk and delivery responsibilities | A fully owned private business delivers public services on behalf of the government to agreed standards | Fully independent private businesses supported and controlled only indirectly by government policies |
| Structure types |
|
|
|
|
|
| Illustrative example |
|
|
|
|
|
| Key advantages |
|
|
|
|
|
| Key limitations |
|
|
|
|
|
Structure types across different ownership options
Link copiedWithin the conceptual ownership categories introduced in Exhibit 2, there are a number of more detailed models that define the responsibility of government and its potential partners.
The ownership model must allocate responsibility for creating and sustaining revenues from the asset and meeting costs for financing and operations. The allocation of these responsibilities is interdependent with the ownership and financing of the asset. Ownership typically affects the bundle of rights and obligations a party will have and thus the balance of incentives that must be defined contractually.
Owner-like behaviour can be incentivised via a contract, even where the private party has no underlying property interest in the asset. Therefore, the operating model and financing approach must be considered in an integrated design exercise, which will often benefit from structured market testing and engagement to steer these choices.
There are 5 structures that projects typically adopt, refer Exhibit 3, noting that this list is not necessarily exhaustive.
This overview may assist entities in identifying potential options as they begin design of the partnership model.
Exhibit 3: Non-exhaustive list of structure types across different ownership options. Governments can invest in ‘private’ through investment instruments including convertibles or debt and/or equity (the latter of which gives government an ownership stake).
Potential ownership options
Public
- Purely public operations - public sector owns and directly operates the asset to provide services.
- Delivery, management and operating contracts - private sector company contracted as strategic partner to provide management or operational services.
- Lease/affermage - operator (leaseholder) responsible for operating and maintaining an existing asset, but generally not required to make large investments.
Private
- Full private ownership and full divestiture - private sector company fully owns an asset it develops or purchases an existing government asset or group of assets.
Mix of public and private
- Concession, Build Operate Transfer (BOT), Design Build Operate (DBO), Design Build Finance Operate (DBFO) - right to generate a revenue stream from an asset is granted to partner for a fixed period of time in exchange for performing bundle services associated with the asset - e.g. building and operating - during the period.
- Joint venture and partial divestiture - private sector company provide assets, financing and/or services in exchange for an ownership stake in the project.
Roles for government in investment
Link copied
Exhibit 4
Government incentivises and steers private sector investment via policy and regulatory settings.
Example forms:
- macro-economic settings
- improvements to the efficiency of the legal system
- certainty of policy direction
- commitment to policy-making approaches
- pricing of externalities
- standard-setting.
Government incentivises private sector investment through spending but does not take ongoing ownership rights.
Example forms:
- grants spent in the market
- favourable tax incentives for investment
- consumer subsidies
- government service contracting and procurement.
Government contributes to capital structure of asset or investment vehicle and partners with one or more other parties as co-investors.
Example forms:
- guarantees
- in-kind financing
- debt interest
- convertible debt interest
- minority equity stake.
Government takes 51-100% of the equity of asset or investment vehicle, with private sector minority investments and/or contractors.
Example forms of equity:
- Government Business Enterprises (GBEs)
- property/infrastructure
- financial assets (Australian Government Investment Funds/Special Investment Vehicles).
Further public and/or private capital via:
- guarantees
- in-kind financing
- debt interest(s)
- convertible debt interest(s)
- minority equity stake(s).
Opportunities for private sector investment to add value
Link copiedTo be capable of investment by the private sector, the asset or project needs a viable commercial model and source of revenue that can be allocated to the investor.
For the allocation of that revenue stream to be efficient and effective, it must be based on policy and/or financial value creation that offsets the private sectors, direct costs, costs of capital, and their expectation for an acceptable risk-adjusted return on the invested capital.
Specifically, where Government is the sole or primary source of revenue for the asset, the investment will need to generate some other benefit to government that offsets the incremental cost of private capital and margin that the private investor will expect. Private partners face a higher cost of capital and their investors expect a return commensurate with the risk. In order to fund this cost of capital and return expectation, the private sector's involvement must generate sufficient value that can be shared and/or used to offset the cost to Government of meeting the private party's return expectations.
'Opportunities for private sector investment to add value' in Exhibit 5 describes the potential sources of this value that a private sector partner can provide. When considering private sector involvement, test whether any of the ways the private sector can add value apply to the subject matter and overall context of the investment.
Exhibit 5: opportunities for private sector to add value
| Policy benefits for government (levers to add value apply to different levels of government i.e. federal, state and territory and local governments) | Reduction of government capital expenditure (capex) | Reduction of government operating expenditure (opex) | Value generation under private operation | User-generated revenue | Commercialisation | |
| Description | Government pays private provider because it values the policy improvements they can deliver | Government pays private provider(s) a share of savings made from lower cost investment in the asset | Government pays private provider(s) a share of savings made from lower cost operation of the asset | Government uses targeted taxation, levies and rates on zones surrounding asset to capture spill-over value | Government gives private provider(s) the right to collect revenue from users | Government gives private provider(s) the right to deploy the asset outside its immediate context |
| Key variants |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Select levers private providers can use to add value |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Key pre-requisites to consider as a viable option |
|
|
|
|
|
|